1. Home
  2. US
  3. New York
  4. Suffolk County
  5. Shelter Island

Hotels Near Shelter Island

Best deals on the hotels closest to this island in Suffolk County, New York

The Harborfront Inn
Book it now at a great price at TheRealPlaces!

209 Front St - Greenport - 3.0 miles from Shelter Island

Near Greenport Carousel
Sound View Greenport
Click for the best price at TheHotelNexus.com

58775 Route 48 - Greenport - 4.0 miles from Shelter Island

Near Railroad Museum of Long Island
White Blossom House Inn
Book it now at a great price at TheRealPlaces!

695 Pine Neck Rd - Southold - 5.2 miles from Shelter Island

Near Croteaux Vineyards
Topping Rose House
Book it now at a great price at TheRealPlaces!

One Bridgehampton - Sag Harbor Turnpike - Bridgehampton - 8.9 miles from Shelter Island

Near Children's Museum of The East End
Capri
Book it now at a great price at TheRealPlaces!

281 County Road 39A - Southampton - 11.8 miles from Shelter Island

Near North Main Street Historic District
The Atlantic Hotel
Book it now at a great price at TheRealPlaces!

1655 County Road 39 - Southampton - 13.3 miles from Shelter Island

Near Shinnecock Hills Golf Course
Sea Haven Resort Motel
Click for the best price at TheHotelNexus.com

52 Longview Road - Southampton - 13.8 miles from Shelter Island

Near Meschutt Beach
Hampton Maid Motel
Click for the best price at TheHotelNexus.com

259 E Montauk Hwy - Hampton Bays - 15.1 miles from Shelter Island

Near Meschutt Beach
Saybrook Point Inn, Marina and Spa
Click for the best price at TheHotelNexus.com

2 Bridge St - Old Saybrook - 15.1 miles from Shelter Island

In Old Saybrook (Old Saybrook Center)
Pier Blue Guesthouse
Book it now at a great price at TheRealPlaces!

1430 Boston Post Rd - Old Saybrook - 15.8 miles from Shelter Island

In Old Saybrook (Saybrook Manor)
Econo Lodge Inn & Suites Old Saybrook Westbrook
Click for the best price at TheHotelNexus.com

1750 Boston Post Rd - Old Saybrook - 15.9 miles from Shelter Island

In Old Saybrook (Westbrook Center)
Water's Edge Resort & Spa
Book it now at a great price at TheRealPlaces!

1525 Boston Post Road - Westbrook - 15.9 miles from Shelter Island

In Westbrook (Westbrook Center)
Super 8 by Wyndham Old Saybrook
Click for the best price at TheHotelNexus.com

37 Spencer Plain Rd - Old Saybrook - 16.1 miles from Shelter Island

In Old Saybrook (Westbrook Center)
Liberty Inn
Book it now at a great price at TheRealPlaces!

55 Springbrook Road - Old Saybrook - 17.2 miles from Shelter Island

Near Katharine Hepburn Cultural Arts Center
Quality Inn Old Saybrook - Westbrook
Book it now at a great price at TheRealPlaces!

100 Essex Rd - Old Saybrook - 17.6 miles from Shelter Island

Near Florence Griswold Museum
Old Lyme Inn
Click for the best price at TheHotelNexus.com

85 Lyme Street - Old Lyme - 18.0 miles from Shelter Island

Near Florence Griswold Museum
Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa
Click for the best price at TheHotelNexus.com

290 Old Montauk Highway - Montauk - 18.1 miles from Shelter Island

Near Hither Woods Preserve
Ruschmeyers Hotel
Click for the best price at TheHotelNexus.com

161 Second House Rd - Montauk - 19.5 miles from Shelter Island

Near Fort Pond Bay Beach
Hyatt Place Long Island East End
Book it now at a great price at TheRealPlaces!

451 East Main Street - Riverhead - 19.6 miles from Shelter Island

Near Long Island Aquarium and Exhibition Center
The Preston House & Hotel
Book it now at a great price at TheRealPlaces!

428 E Main Street - Riverhead - 19.7 miles from Shelter Island

Near Long Island Aquarium and Exhibition Center