1. Home
  2. US
  3. New York
  4. Suffolk County
  5. Gardiners Island

Hotels Near Gardiners Island

Best deals on the hotels closest to this island in Suffolk County, New York

Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa
Book it now at a great price at TheRealPlaces!

290 Old Montauk Highway - Montauk - 8.1 miles from Gardiners Island

Near Hither Woods Preserve
Ruschmeyers Hotel
Book it now at a great price at TheRealPlaces!

161 Second House Rd - Montauk - 8.5 miles from Gardiners Island

Near Fort Pond Bay Beach
Sunset Beach Motel
Click for the best price at TheHotelNexus.com

540 West Lake Drive - Montauk - 8.5 miles from Gardiners Island

In Montauk (Culloden Shores)
The Surf Lodge
Book it now at a great price at TheRealPlaces!

183 Edgemere St - Montauk - 8.8 miles from Gardiners Island

Near Fort Pond
Gurney’s Star Island Resort & Marina
Click for the best price at TheHotelNexus.com

32 Star Island Rd - Montauk - 9.1 miles from Gardiners Island

Near Montauk Marine Basin
Ocean Surf Resort
Book it now at a great price at TheRealPlaces!

84 South Emerson Avenue - Montauk - 9.4 miles from Gardiners Island

Near South Edison Beach
Daunt's Albatross Motel
Click for the best price at TheHotelNexus.com

44 South Elmwood Ave - Montauk - 9.4 miles from Gardiners Island

Near South Edison Beach
The Harborfront Inn
Book it now at a great price at TheRealPlaces!

209 Front St - Greenport - 13.5 miles from Gardiners Island

Near Greenport Carousel
Topping Rose House
Click for the best price at TheHotelNexus.com

One Bridgehampton - Sag Harbor Turnpike - Bridgehampton - 15.1 miles from Gardiners Island

Near Children's Museum of The East End
Sound View Greenport
Click for the best price at TheHotelNexus.com

58775 Route 48 - Greenport - 15.3 miles from Gardiners Island

Near Railroad Museum of Long Island
White Blossom House Inn
Book it now at a great price at TheRealPlaces!

695 Pine Neck Rd - Southold - 17.4 miles from Gardiners Island

Near Croteaux Vineyards
Holiday Inn New London - Mystic Area
Click for the best price at TheHotelNexus.com

35 Governor Winthrop Blvd - New London - 17.9 miles from Gardiners Island

Near United States Coast Guard Academy
Hampton Inn Groton/Mystic/New London
Book it now at a great price at TheRealPlaces!

300 Long Hill Rd - Groton - 18.1 miles from Gardiners Island

Near Fort Griswold Battlefield State Park
Saybrook Point Inn, Marina and Spa
Click for the best price at TheHotelNexus.com

2 Bridge St - Old Saybrook - 18.2 miles from Gardiners Island

In Old Saybrook (Old Saybrook Center)
Motel 6 Groton CT
Book it now at a great price at TheRealPlaces!

404 Bridge St - Groton - 18.2 miles from Gardiners Island

Near United States Coast Guard Academy
Rodeway Inn
Book it now at a great price at TheRealPlaces!

425 Bridge St - Groton - 18.3 miles from Gardiners Island

Near United States Coast Guard Academy
Groton Inn and Suites
Book it now at a great price at TheRealPlaces!

99 Gold Star Highway - Groton - 18.6 miles from Gardiners Island

Near Fort Griswold Battlefield State Park
Days Inn by Wyndham Niantic Near Casinos
Click for the best price at TheHotelNexus.com

239 Flanders Road - Niantic - 18.7 miles from Gardiners Island

Near Cedar Ridge Golf Course
Super 8 by Wyndham Groton
Book it now at a great price at TheRealPlaces!

173, Route 12 - Groton - 18.7 miles from Gardiners Island

Near United States Coast Guard Academy
Ramada by Wyndham Groton
Book it now at a great price at TheRealPlaces!

156 Kings Hwy - Groton - 18.8 miles from Gardiners Island

Near Fort Griswold Battlefield State Park